Review: A Frozen Hell

A Frozen Hell: The Russo-Finnish Winter War of 1939-40


William Trotter’s A Frozen Hell is a pop-history but detailed account of the Winter War. I already knew the course and reasons of the war, but was still impressed by its narrative. For those who do not, it is a spectacular lesson. This alone would be reason enough to wholeheartedly endorse it. But its evenhandedness makes it so much better.

Full disclosure: I consider the WW2/Winter War Finnish Army to be one of, if not THE most overrated armed forces of all time. Trotter clearly loves and respects the Finns who fought against a much stronger opponent (I still do too) but is not shy about pointing out their limitations and poor decisions. (He tears into the “Motti” strategy as actually counterproductive since once the enemy was halted, it became an attrition battle they were badly suited for). They didn’t win the opening battles so much as the unprepared for resistance Soviets lost them, and once they re-attacked with proper planning and firepower, the outcome never was in doubt.

Even politically, he gives a fair shot. Trotter notes that yes, there were legitimate concerns about how if Finland fell to the Germans, Leningrad would be theirs for the taking. He also points out that the Soviets had no desire to re-annex all of Finland if flipping it politically failed (as of course it did), given how they had the country at their feet in 1940 and 1944 and did not move into modern-day Finland proper.

So yes, this is worthy of a Fuldapocalypse recommendation.

The Pokemon Gridiron Lineup

A website called All22pokemon lets you make an American Football team out of the monsters. Here’s my Gen 1 lineup.

Big burly types for the offensive line. One fast electric and two fliers for the wideouts. I had a rule for “receivers need hands or some form to catch”, but broke it to include Tauros, the most powerful Gen I Pokemon without “Mew” in its name. The Quarterback is Alakazam, because of course you want a telekentic with an IQ of 5000 who can teleport.

Defensively, fast electrics for corners (scientists have noticed how dominant these types are at the position), a defensive line that can literally cover the field with their bodies save for one left edge rusher, two immovable blobs at inside linebackers, a generalist right outside linebacker and an LT style fast anti-pass edge rushbacker to the left. Speedy normals serve as the safeties.

Review: Ankoku Shinwa

Ankoku Shinwa (Dark Myth)

From the pen of horror mangaka Morohoshi Daijiro came Ankoku Shinwa, a seven chapter manga from 1976 that was turned into a two episode OVA in 1990. In it, teenager Takeshi finds he is simply a force in a cosmic war of gods and feuding ancient families. Its art is good, especially the monsters. Nothing else is.

The fact that a seven chapter manga was shrunk to two episodes without missing much tells a lot. What you get is the following:

  • Good drawings/animations of monsters and mythical beings (again, the art has little complaint)
  • CONSTANT exposition on the jumble of Asian religions that make up the backstory/reason for the manga
  • Set pieces that only exist to provide the base for more exposition.
  • Human villains who do nothing except fall victim to the Indiana Jones Villain Fate where they try to use something supernatural with predictably poor results.
  • All of the above happens very, very slowly.

On one hand, the OVA is inevitably faster than the text manga. On the other, it has the production values of what you’d expect a low budget OVA to have. So… not really ideal either way. It’s a shame, the concept could have been done better.

Review: Boeing 707 Group

Boeing 707 Group

Graham Simons’ next book about Boeing planes I’m reviewing is not as good as the 737 book. This is about the 707. It is also full of British sour grapes and has no coherence, talking about things like LBJ’s swearing in and the book/movie Airport (!). There are much better technical resources on the 707 that don’t involve strawmen.

The 707 does deserve to be taken down to earth a little, but this book is a full-bore Controlled Flight Into Terrain.

Yep, This Is It

So my time for Fuldapocalypse has basically ended. Am I outright stopping the blog the way I did for the Creative Corner? No. However, and this is important, I no longer feel obligated to update it. So if I make one post every few months or move to a different platform or just leave it (don’t worry, I will keep it up as an archive) I don’t know. But Fuldapocalypse has ceased to be really interesting for me as a creative endeavor.

But I’m not sad or angry or disappointed. Fuldapocalypse started as a way to try and catalog a genre (conventional 1980s WW3) I thought was huge. It turned out to be too small to support a blog and my format too limiting. But then I found that it could become a general review blog. Then a general blog. I wrote and read and expanded all my horizons so massively. I could finally open my eyes and see the elephant in front of me.

So this blog has provided eight (!) great years of content, fun, and education. I remain extremely proud of it.

Fulda, Germany, a fitting photo for this announcement.

Literary Survivorship Bias

People are lamenting, and not unreasonably so, that people are losing the ability to process literature. However, I believe that A: Such a thing did not really exist, and B: If it did, it was something along the lines of “past generations knew how to ride horses better.”

I think the reason is survivorship bias, which my reading of decades worth of cheap thrillers has shown. Basically, people see the literary works that endured in popular conciousness, not the far cruder ones people actually read.

Review: Boeing 737

Boeing 737: The World’s Most Controversial Commercial Jetliner

Graham Simons brings his aviation writing talents to work on the archetypical airliner, the 737. His book is fittingly named Boeing 737. In it, he tells the full long story of a plane that was at first believed to be an ugly duckling nobody wanted, that ironically survived in its early period due to a government contract, became the world-beating airliner extraordinaire, and got pushed forward past its diminishing returns in the present.

The early 737 survived on exports as union requirements for three crew despite the aircraft being designed only for two from the start, with United the only major American operator. Despite this slow start, it became the centerpiece of a company.

I would say that this book is excellent but has the problem of being broader than it is deep. For instance, we get long writeups of individual operators complete with huge photos and detailed descriptions of individual accidents like the Aloha Airlines loss of the roof. Yet, the word “deregulation” (the Airline Deregulation Act and its equivalents internationally) only appears once. As this was what propelled the 737 to its heights, such a context would be much appreciated. But as a coffee table book this is wonderful.

Review: The Quiet War

The Quiet War

I must confess by this point I read The Quiet War just because I wanted to see just how far down Mark Hewitt’s Duncan Hunter series could go. Two chapters in, I was not disappointed. We get a padded flashback chapter where every single technical name is spelled out in full like it was a late Gold Eagle book, and then an example of the gargantuan homophobia the series became infamous for. And another. And another. The “flashback” chapters reach double digits, treating us to such horrors from the main character’s perspective as The Beatles.

This is not a book about a super-plane, even though there’s a chapter where it effortlessly crushes its opposition (like it has always done in the series). This is a book about gay communists. This sounds like some online insult, but it’s actually the factual book subject matter (besides said squash and a past article about the main character finding a treasure chest.) Tirades about how a cabal of gay communists were steered by the USSR into sabotaging America make up most of this. And the previous book. And…

So this isn’t even amusingly bad. It’s just on repeat.