Review: A Frozen Hell

A Frozen Hell: The Russo-Finnish Winter War of 1939-40


William Trotter’s A Frozen Hell is a pop-history but detailed account of the Winter War. I already knew the course and reasons of the war, but was still impressed by its narrative. For those who do not, it is a spectacular lesson. This alone would be reason enough to wholeheartedly endorse it. But its evenhandedness makes it so much better.

Full disclosure: I consider the WW2/Winter War Finnish Army to be one of, if not THE most overrated armed forces of all time. Trotter clearly loves and respects the Finns who fought against a much stronger opponent (I still do too) but is not shy about pointing out their limitations and poor decisions. (He tears into the “Motti” strategy as actually counterproductive since once the enemy was halted, it became an attrition battle they were badly suited for). They didn’t win the opening battles so much as the unprepared for resistance Soviets lost them, and once they re-attacked with proper planning and firepower, the outcome never was in doubt.

Even politically, he gives a fair shot. Trotter notes that yes, there were legitimate concerns about how if Finland fell to the Germans, Leningrad would be theirs for the taking. He also points out that the Soviets had no desire to re-annex all of Finland if flipping it politically failed (as of course it did), given how they had the country at their feet in 1940 and 1944 and did not move into modern-day Finland proper.

So yes, this is worthy of a Fuldapocalypse recommendation.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.